cmake-based ports: add cmake.out_of_source yes/no

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

Following #33259 and r134128 it would be nice if maintainers of ports using the cmake PortGroup would add the following line to their ports

cmake.out_of_source yes

and test whether the ports still compile fine (no need for a revbump). Some ports already use out-of-source builds, so those ports would need a minor clean-up.

If the port doesn't work that way, please add an explicit

cmake.out_of_source no

with a short comment (and possibly file an upstream bug report).

Once all the ports are tested, this would become the default behaviour and the line (setting yes) will be removed from the ports.

List of affected ports (not necessarily up to date):

Ports which require maintainer approval

• PlasmaClient (ryandesign):
• PlasmaShop (ryandesign):
• alps (gmail.com:gamperl):
• apbs (gmail.com:howarth.at.macports):
• autopano-sift-c (auckland.ac.nz:p.schmiedeskamp,gmail.com:hvdwolf):
• cgal (vince):
• coinor-liblemon (@BSeppke):
• fann (gmail.com:mwilliams256):
• flann (mmoll): ?
• gmt5 (eprofs.de:florian,takeshi): r134283
• gnudatalanguage (takeshi): r134284
• gnuradio (michaelld): r134164
• h3dutil (sensegraphics.com:support): r134471
• htcondor (aronnax): a58ca40049
• indi (gmail.com:ferran.casarramona):
• indi_maxdomeii (gmail.com:ferran.casarramona):
• kealib (vince):
• libbiosig (gmx.de:christsc): r134178
• libhsplasma (ryandesign):
• liblas (gmail.com:venabled):
• libnifalcon (gmail.com:richardsjohnt): r135988
• libpcl (gmail.com:luminans,vince):
• magicspp (takeshi): r134297
• metis (sean):
• ogre (gmail.com:marin.saric):
• ompl (mmoll):
• oxygen-icons (nicos): r134217
• pgrouting (vince):
• physfs (users.sourceforge.net:luiji):
• piklab (bmstu.ru:gav):
• playerstage-player (ai.sri.com:vincent):
• playerstage-stage (ai.sri.com:vincent):
• qgis (vince):
• qhull (mmoll):
• qlandkartegt (puffin.lb.shuttle.de:michael.klein,mk):
• qlandkartegt-garmindev (puffin.lb.shuttle.de:michael.klein,mk):
• qore-qt4-module (scribus.info:petr):
• root6 (hep.phy.cam.ac.uk:jonesc,mojca): r134138
• rsgislib (vince):
• seqan-apps (fu-berlin.de:david.weese):
• sfcgal (vince):
• streamlog (gmail.com:gtolemans):
• uhd (michaelld): r134170
• vigra (gmail.com:benjamin.seppke):

Ports with openmaintainer

• Bear (cal,openmaintainer): r134188
• OpenGTL (gmail.com:mschamschula,openmaintainer): r134172
• TOra (pvanek,openmaintainer):
• airspy (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134227
• armadillo (gmail.com:christian.frisson,openmaintainer):
• assimp (openmaintainer,mmoll): ?
• bladeRF (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134224
• blosc (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• box2d (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• bullet (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• ceres-solver (mmoll,openmaintainer): ?
• charm (gmail.com:rjvbertin,mk,openmaintainer):
• chipmunk (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• chromaprint (khindenburg,openmaintainer): r134479
• clhep (mojca,openmaintainer): r134136
• clucene (free.fr:dinh.viet.hoa,openmaintainer):
• dcmtk (eborisch,openmaintainer): r135597
• dolfin (sean,openmaintainer):
• efte (reiffert,openmaintainer):
• eigen (nicos,openmaintainer): r134215
• eigen3 (eborisch,openmaintainer): r140077
• exiv2 (vafer.org:tcurdt,openmaintainer):
• falcon (snc,openmaintainer):
• fcl (mmoll,openmaintainer):
• freealut (gmail.com:lubodiakov,openmaintainer): 72637ad0
• freecad (gmail.com:mark.brethen,openmaintainer):
• gate (mojca,openmaintainer): r134133
• geant4 (mojca,openmaintainer): r134132
• gerbil (cal,openmaintainer): r134191
• glfw (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134225
• gr-air-modes (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134241
• gr-ais (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134240
• gr-baz (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134239
• gr-dvbs (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134238
• gr-dvbs2 (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134237
• gr-dvbt (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134236
• gr-fcdproplus (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134235
• gr-fosphor (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134233
• gr-iqbalance (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134232
• gr-mac (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134231
• gr-osmosdr (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134230
• gr-rds (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134229
• graphite2 (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• hackrf (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134226
• iAIDA (mojca,gmail.com:apfeiffer1,openmaintainer): r134134
• kst (nicos,openmaintainer): r134216
• lensfun (devans,openmaintainer): r134153
• lib2geom (devans,openmaintainer): r134154
• libLASi (takeshi,openmaintainer): r134298
• libccd (mmoll,openmaintainer):
• libdynd (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• libftdi (snc,openmaintainer):
• libgit2 (juanrgar,devans,openmaintainer): r134155
• liblastfm (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134242
• libphonenumber-cpp (devans,openmaintainer): r134156
• libproxy (devans,openmaintainer): r134157
• libssh (cal,openmaintainer): r134187
• libtuxcap (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• lmms (ryandesign,openmaintainer): r135968
• mariadb (pixilla,openmaintainer): r137069
• mariadb-10.0 (pixilla,openmaintainer): r137069
• mariadb-10.1 (pixilla,openmaintainer): r137069
• mysql55 (pixilla,openmaintainer): r137069
• mysql55-connector-cpp (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• mysql56 (pixilla,openmaintainer): r137069
• nomacs (pvanek,openmaintainer):
• oce (gmail.com:mark.brethen,openmaintainer):
• openal-soft (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• openbabel (mac.com:mlund,openmaintainer):
• opencv (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• openjpeg (mcalhoun,openmaintainer): r138982
• orfeotoolbox (gmail.com:julien.malik,stromnov,openmaintainer): r136969
• parmetis (sean,openmaintainer):
• pdf2htmlex (iapa.in:iapain,mojca,openmaintainer): r134135
• pdfpc (cal,openmaintainer): r134192
• percona (mac.com:quest,openmaintainer): r137069
• phonon (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134243
• phonon-backend-gstreamer (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134247
• podofo (devans,openmaintainer): r134159
• pqp (mmoll,openmaintainer): ?
• py-dynd (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• py-pyside (openmaintainer,mmoll): ?
• py-pyside-tools (openmaintainer,mmoll): ?
• py-shiboken (openmaintainer,mmoll):
• qlipper (pvanek,openmaintainer):
• quassel (sicherha,openmaintainer):
• rabbitmq-c (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• rspamd (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• rtl-sdr (michaelld,openmaintainer): r134246
• scalapack (sean,openmaintainer):
• scantailor (raphael,openmaintainer): r148275
• sdcv (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• shogun-devel (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• sigil (openmaintainer,krischik):
• soci (rmh.de:g.lorenz,openmaintainer):
• sysdig (g5pw,openmaintainer): r147845
• tagainijisho (strasweb.fr:rudloff,openmaintainer):
• telepathy-qt (nicos,openmaintainer): r135178
• tinyxml (openmaintainer,mmoll): r134144
• viennacl (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• vramsteg (raimue,openmaintainer): r134597
• vtk (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• weechat (gmail.com:starkhalo,openmaintainer): r137362
• xrootd (hep.phy.cam.ac.uk:jonesc,openmaintainer): r139539
• yajl (gmail.com:benjaminlyu,openmaintainer): r139535
• yaml-cpp (the-huck.com:patrick,openmaintainer): r139538

Ports with nomaintainer

• Cockatrice:
• FreeRDP: r135596
• Io:
• LucenePlusPlus: r141818
• OpenSceneGraph: r146106
• OpenSceneGraph-devel: r146109
• Vidalia:
• allegro:
• allegro5: ce43624d
• apiextractor:
• assimp2:
• avidemux: r141390
• chemkit:
• choqok:
• clucene-devel:
• collada-dom:
• cuneiform: r136891
• cutecom-qt4-mac: r148651
• ebook-tools:
• emergent:
• ettercap:
• freecell-solver:
• gccxml-devel: r148679
• generatorrunner:
• gl2ps: r135599
• gmsh: r134173
• hugin-app: r134470
• json_spirit:
• libmsn:
• libmusicbrainz3:
• libplist:
• lua-luabitop: r140260
• newmat:
• nifticlib:
• orocos-kdl:
• orocos-rtt:
• osgswig-devel:
• polkit-qt:
• portmidi:
• qfsm:
• scribus: r137847
• synergy:
• synergy-devel:
• taglib: r139536
• task: r139537
• tigervnc: r138607
• toluapp:
• usbmuxd:
• vrpn: r141020
• vtk5:
• vxl:
• wbxml2: ac51b298
• wesnoth: r139534
• widelands: r153719
• wxLua: r134469
• zorba: r139532

Other

• kde4-1.1.tcl: r134210

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

(list of ports removed)

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

@mojca: Here's the list with maintainers specified. It should probably be put in the description so anyone can update the list. I can edit this comment and remove this if you don't want it.

Ports which require maintainer approval

• PlasmaClient (ryandesign):
• PlasmaShop (ryandesign):
• alps (gmail.com:gamperl):
• apbs (gmail.com:howarth.at.macports):
• autopano-sift-c (auckland.ac.nz:p.schmiedeskamp,gmail.com:hvdwolf):
• bob (idiap.ch:andre.anjos,idiap.ch:laurent.el-shafey):
• cgal (vince):
• coinor-liblemon (fu-berlin.de:david.weese,cs.elte.hu:alpar):
• cutecom-qt4-mac (tds.net:jwbacon):
• fann (gmail.com:mwilliams256):
• flann (mmoll):
• gmt5 (eprofs.de:florian,takeshi):
• gnudatalanguage (takeshi):
• gnuradio (michaelld):
• h3dutil (sensegraphics.com:support):
• htcondor (aronnax):
• indi (gmail.com:ferran.casarramona):
• indi_maxdomeii (gmail.com:ferran.casarramona):
• kealib (vince):
• libbiosig (gmx.de:christsc):
• libhsplasma (ryandesign):
• liblas (gmail.com:venabled):
• libnifalcon (gmail.com:richardsjohnt):
• libpcl (gmail.com:luminans,vince):
• magicspp (takeshi):
• metis (sean):
• ogre (gmail.com:marin.saric):
• ompl (mmoll):
• oxygen-icons (nicos):
• pgrouting (vince):
• physfs (users.sourceforge.net:luiji):
• piklab (bmstu.ru:gav):
• playerstage-player (ai.sri.com:vincent):
• playerstage-stage (ai.sri.com:vincent):
• qgis (vince):
• qhull (mmoll):
• qlandkartegt (puffin.lb.shuttle.de:michael.klein,mk):
• qlandkartegt-garmindev (puffin.lb.shuttle.de:michael.klein,mk):
• qore-qt4-module (scribus.info:petr):
• root6 (hep.phy.cam.ac.uk:jonesc,mojca):
• rsgislib (vince):
• seqan-apps (fu-berlin.de:david.weese):
• sfcgal (vince):
• streamlog (gmail.com:gtolemans):
• uhd (michaelld):
• vigra (gmail.com:benjamin.seppke):

Ports with openmaintainer

• Bear (cal,openmaintainer):
• OpenGTL (gmail.com:mschamschula,openmaintainer):
• TOra (pvanek,openmaintainer):
• airspy (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• armadillo (gmail.com:christian.frisson,openmaintainer):
• assimp (openmaintainer,mmoll):
• bladeRF (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• blosc (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• box2d (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• bullet (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• ceres-solver (mmoll,openmaintainer):
• charm (gmail.com:rjvbertin,mk,openmaintainer):
• chipmunk (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• chromaprint (khindenburg,openmaintainer):
• clhep (mojca,openmaintainer):
• clucene (free.fr:dinh.viet.hoa,openmaintainer):
• dcmtk (eborisch,openmaintainer):
• dolfin (sean,openmaintainer):
• efte (reiffert,openmaintainer):
• eigen (nicos,openmaintainer):
• eigen3 (eborisch,openmaintainer):
• exiv2 (vafer.org:tcurdt,openmaintainer):
• falcon (snc,openmaintainer):
• fcl (mmoll,openmaintainer):
• freealut (gmail.com:lubodiakov,openmaintainer):
• freecad (gmail.com:mark.brethen,openmaintainer):
• gate (mojca,openmaintainer):
• geant4 (mojca,openmaintainer):
• gerbil (cal,openmaintainer):
• glfw (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-air-modes (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-ais (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-baz (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-dvbs (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-dvbs2 (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-dvbt (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-fcdproplus (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-fosphor (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-iqbalance (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-mac (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-osmosdr (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• gr-rds (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• graphite2 (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• hackrf (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• iAIDA (mojca,gmail.com:apfeiffer1,openmaintainer):
• kst (nicos,openmaintainer):
• lensfun (devans,openmaintainer):
• lib2geom (devans,openmaintainer):
• libLASi (takeshi,openmaintainer):
• libccd (mmoll,openmaintainer):
• libdynd (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• libftdi (snc,openmaintainer):
• libgit2 (juanrgar,devans,openmaintainer):
• liblastfm (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• libphonenumber-cpp (devans,openmaintainer):
• libproxy (devans,openmaintainer):
• libssh (cal,openmaintainer):
• libtuxcap (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• lmms (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• mariadb (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• mariadb-10.0 (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• mariadb-10.1 (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• mysql55 (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• mysql55-connector-cpp (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• mysql56 (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• nomacs (pvanek,openmaintainer):
• oce (gmail.com:mark.brethen,openmaintainer):
• openal-soft (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• openbabel (mac.com:mlund,openmaintainer):
• opencv (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• openjpeg (mcalhoun,openmaintainer):
• orfeotoolbox (gmail.com:julien.malik,stromnov,openmaintainer):
• parmetis (sean,openmaintainer):
• pdf2htmlex (iapa.in:iapain,mojca,openmaintainer):
• pdfpc (cal,openmaintainer):
• percona (mac.com:quest,openmaintainer):
• phonon (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• phonon-backend-gstreamer (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• podofo (devans,openmaintainer):
• pqp (mmoll,openmaintainer):
• py-dynd (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• py-pyside (openmaintainer,mmoll):
• py-pyside-tools (openmaintainer,mmoll):
• py-shiboken (openmaintainer,mmoll):
• qlipper (pvanek,openmaintainer):
• quassel (sicherha,openmaintainer):
• rabbitmq-c (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• rspamd (pixilla,openmaintainer):
• rtl-sdr (michaelld,openmaintainer):
• scalapack (sean,openmaintainer):
• scantailor (raphael,openmaintainer):
• sdcv (ryandesign,openmaintainer):
• shogun-devel (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• sigil (openmaintainer,krischik):
• soci (rmh.de:g.lorenz,openmaintainer):
• sysdig (g5pw,openmaintainer):
• tagainijisho (strasweb.fr:rudloff,openmaintainer):
• telepathy-qt (nicos,openmaintainer):
• tinyxml (openmaintainer,mmoll):
• viennacl (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• vramsteg (raimue,openmaintainer):
• vtk (stromnov,openmaintainer):
• weechat (gmail.com:starkhalo,openmaintainer):
• xrootd (hep.phy.cam.ac.uk:jonesc,openmaintainer):
• yajl (gmail.com:benjaminlyu,openmaintainer):
• yaml-cpp (the-huck.com:patrick,openmaintainer):

Ports with nomaintainer

• Cockatrice (nomaintainer):
• FreeRDP (nomaintainer):
• Io (nomaintainer):
• LucenePlusPlus (nomaintainer):
• OpenSceneGraph (nomaintainer):
• OpenSceneGraph-devel (nomaintainer):
• Vidalia (nomaintainer):
• allegro (nomaintainer):
• allegro5 (nomaintainer):
• apiextractor (nomaintainer):
• assimp2 (nomaintainer):
• avidemux (nomaintainer):
• chemkit (nomaintainer):
• choqok (nomaintainer):
• clucene-devel (nomaintainer):
• collada-dom (nomaintainer):
• cuneiform (nomaintainer):
• ebook-tools (nomaintainer):
• emergent (nomaintainer):
• ettercap (nomaintainer):
• freecell-solver (nomaintainer):
• gccxml-devel (nomaintainer):
• generatorrunner (nomaintainer):
• gl2ps (nomaintainer):
• gmsh (nomaintainer):
• hugin-app (nomaintainer):
• json_spirit (nomaintainer):
• libmsn (nomaintainer):
• libmusicbrainz3 (nomaintainer):
• libplist (nomaintainer):
• lua-luabitop (nomaintainer):
• newmat (nomaintainer):
• nifticlib (nomaintainer):
• orocos-kdl (nomaintainer):
• orocos-rtt (nomaintainer):
• osgswig-devel (nomaintainer):
• polkit-qt (nomaintainer):
• portmidi (nomaintainer):
• qfsm (nomaintainer):
• scribus (nomaintainer):
• synergy (nomaintainer):
• synergy-devel (nomaintainer):
• taglib (nomaintainer):
• task (nomaintainer):
• tigervnc (nomaintainer):
• toluapp (nomaintainer):
• usbmuxd (nomaintainer):
• vrpn (nomaintainer):
• vtk5 (nomaintainer):
• vxl (nomaintainer):
• wbxml2 (nomaintainer):
• wesnoth (nomaintainer):
• widelands (nomaintainer):
• wxLua (nomaintainer):
• zorba (nomaintainer):

[Schamschula (Marius Schamschula)]

Fixed Portfile for OpenGTL

[Schamschula (Marius Schamschula)]

Fixed Portfile for armadillo

[mamoll (Mark Moll)]

I have committed fixes for ports for which I am listed as maintainer: assimp, ceres-solver, fcl, flann, libccd, ompl, pqp, py-pyside, py-pyside-tools, py-shiboken, qhull, and tinyxml.

[Schamschula (Marius Schamschula)]

I've updated the Portfiles for OpenGTL (I'm the maintainer), armadillo (openmaintainer) and gmash (nomaintainer). All three build w/o any problems.

[neurodroid (Christoph Schmidt-Hieber)]

Fixed Portfile for libbiosig

[richardsjohnt@…]

I'm the maintainer of the Portfile for libnifalcon, though I haven't used it in a few years. I tried to build it using the current Portfile on Yosemite, but it failed. Additionally, I think the project may have been abandoned (last commit was 2ish years ago). Maybe it's time to prune this port?

[larryv (Lawrence Velázquez)]

r134172: OpenGTL, r134173: gmsh

[larryv (Lawrence Velázquez)]

r134178: libbiosig

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

What exactly is the idea after having confirmed that things still work with cmake.out_of_source yes? Submit with that line in place, or remove it again, and let things follow their course?

[larryv (Lawrence Velázquez)]

The former.

Eventually, all ports using cmake-1.0 will contain either “cmake.out_of_source yes” or “cmake.out_of_source no”. At that point, we’ll switch the default to “yes” and remove all the “cmake.out_of_source yes” lines (this is easily automated).

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

There's one niggle with that scheme: ports that currently use out-of-source because they are obliged to. We lose trace of that if you remove all OOS setters when it becomes the default, breaking things if ever for whatever reason the default is switched back to non-OOS.

[larryv (Lawrence Velázquez)]

Replying to rjvbertin@…:

There's one niggle with that scheme: ports that currently use out-of-source because they are obliged to. We lose trace of that if you remove all OOS setters when it becomes the default, breaking things if ever for whatever reason the default is switched back to non-OOS.

Why this would ever happen? And in the event that it does happen, presumably we’d go through this testing process again.

We don’t apply this logic anywhere else. Ports that install using make install don’t all explictly set destroot.target install to defend against possible changes to the default value.

This is getting off-topic.

[dbevans (David B. Evans)]

Ports that I maintain are now updated

• lensfun r134153
• lib2geom r134154
• libgit2 r134155
• libphonenumber-cpp r134156
• libproxy r134157
• podofo r134159

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

The ports I (co)maintain and that don't depend on the KDE4 portgroup (I provided a patch for that one to mk, who'll commit it)

• Vc: ticket:46774
• libical: comment:ticket:44469:13
• ECM: comment:ticket:46978:19
• oxygen-gtk{2,3}: comment:ticket:43971:3

[Schamschula (Marius Schamschula)]

I saw rjvb's comment regarding my Vc port. I hadn't updated the Portfile as the port hasn't officially been added to MacPorts: #46774 is still open. I did test his updated Portfile, with

cmake.out_of_source yes

in place: no problems here.

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

Replying to mschamschula@…:

I saw rjvb's comment regarding my Vc port.

As a matter of fact, we created almost exactly the same Portfile independently; you just beat me to submitting it :)

[neverpanic (Clemens Lang)]

• Bear: r134188, with a version update
• libssh: r134187, did previously require OOS build
• gerbil: r134191, fix build
• pdfpc: r134192

[mkae (Marko Käning)]

• Port-group kde4-1.1: r134210

[sicherha@…]

• quassel: r134161

[NicosPavlov]

eigen: r134215
kst: r134216
oxygen-icons: r134217

telepathy-qt is on hold, as some dependencies do not compile presently

[michaelld (Michael Dickens)]

I think these are all of the ports I'm listed on:

• gnuradio: r134164
• uhd: r134170
• bladeRF: r134224
• glfw: r134225
• phonon: r134243
• phonon-backend-gstreamer: r134247
• liblastfm: r134242
• gr-air-modes: r134241
• gr-ais: r134240
• gr-baz: r134239
• gr-dvbs: r134238
• gr-dvbs2: r134237
• gr-dvbt: r134236
• gr-fcdproplus: r134235
• gr-fosphor: r134233
• gr-iqbalance: r134232
• gr-mac: r134231
• gr-osmosdr: r134230
• gr-rds: r134229
• airspy: r134227
• hackrf: r134226
• rtl-sdr: r134246

[tenomoto (Takeshi Enomoto)]

• gmt5: r134283
• gnudatalanguage: r134284
• magicspp: r134297
• libLASi: r134298

[daniel.evestedt@…]

Fixed Portfile for h3dutil.

[daniel.evestedt@…]

Also updated the Portfiles and versions for the following ports that have not been added to the repository yet. Could someone please have a look and add them as h3dutil by itself does not do much?

• hapi: #38920
• h3dapi: #38921
• h3dmedx3d: #38923
• h3dui: #38922
• h3dphysics: #38924
• h3dload: #38925
• h3dviewer: #38926

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

My ports:

• clhep r134136
• gate r134133
• geant4 r134132
• iAIDA r134134
• pdf2htmlex r134135
• root6 r134138

Others:

• wxlua r134469
• hugin-app r134470
• h3dutil r134471 (request sent from a different email address; hopefully from the maintainer)

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

(Not to be taken seriously.)

Replying to larryv@…:

Replying to rjvbertin@…:

There's one niggle with that scheme: ports that currently use out-of-source because they are obliged to. We lose trace of that if you remove all OOS setters when it becomes the default, breaking things if ever for whatever reason the default is switched back to non-OOS.

Why this would ever happen? And in the event that it does happen, presumably we’d go through this testing process again.

We don’t apply this logic anywhere else.

When testing individual ports I sometimes get a feeling that it could be nice to distinguish between yes, no and dontcare to distinguish between ports that only work with out-of-source, ports where out-of-source fails and ports that work under both regimes.

But of course that would be a waste of resources without any real benefit.

[kurthindenburg (Kurt Hindenburg)]

chromaprint: r134479

[raimue (Rainer Müller)]

• vramsteg: r134597

[petrrr]

Cc Me!

[NicosPavlov]

Telepathy-qt done in r135178.

[dbevans (David B. Evans)]

FreeRDP: r135596.

[petrrr]

Cc Me!

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

• gl2ps: r135599

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

lmms: r135968

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

libnifalcon: r135988

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

cuneiform: r136891

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

orfeotoolbox: r136969

[lubodiakov@…]

Includes cmake.out_of_source yes plus 10.5/10.4 tweaks

[pixilla (Bradley Giesbrecht)]

mariadb, mariadb-10.0, mariadb-10.1, mysql55, mysql56 and percona: r137069

[kurthindenburg (Kurt Hindenburg)]

weechat r137362

[dbevans (David B. Evans)]

scribus r137847

[SickTeddyBear]

Cc Me!

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

tigervnc: r138607

[michaelld (Michael Dickens)]

hackrf was done in r134226, and that's my last port so I'm removing myself from the cc list.

[MarcusCalhoun-Lopez (Marcus Calhoun-Lopez)]

openjpeg changed in r138982.

[ryandesign (Ryan Carsten Schmidt)]

• tinyxml: r134144
• zorba: r139532
• wesnoth: r139534
• yajl: r139535
• taglib: r139536
• task: r139537
• yaml-cpp: r139538
• xrootd: r139539

[eborisch (Eric A. Borisch)]

Updated / removed

• dcmtk: r135597
• eigen3[-devel]: r140077

[mamoll (Mark Moll)]

Removed: assimp, ceres-solver, fcl, flann, libccd, ompl, pqp, py-pyside, py-pyside-tools, py-shiboken, qhull

[michaelld (Michael Dickens)]

avidemux done in r141390.

[tcurdt@…]

Cc Me!

[raphael-st (Raphael Straub)]

scantailor done in r148275.

[g5pw (Aljaž Srebrnič)]

Sysdig was updated in r147845.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

Removed jwbacon from Cc since he retired. See #51305.

[neurodroid (Christoph Schmidt-Hieber)]

Cc Me!

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

cutecom-qt4-mac done in r148651.

[dbevans (David B. Evans)]

py-bob-* has its own build system which uses cmake but not the portgroup. Removing it from this ticket.

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

• kde-1.0.tcl: r134210

That's kde4-1.1.tcl, in fact ;)

[mkae (Marko Käning)]

Thanks for notifying that, René! :)

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

In ac51b298/macports-ports:

wbxml2: upgrade to 0.11.4

• Upgrade to version 0.11.4
• Add cmake.out_of_source yes
• Avoid installing FindLibWbxml2.cmake to version-dependent location ${prefix}/share/cmake-3.7/Modules/FindLibWbxml2.cmake

See: #47197

[lpsinger (Leo Singer)]

htcondor done in a58ca40049

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

ports can also start migrating to the cmake 1.1 portgroup.

[larryv (Lawrence Velázquez)]

I would recommend against this until we nail the new API down. Off-topic, anyway.

[RJVB (René Bertin)]

Not really; new features aside the v1.1 PG sets cmake.out_of_source, and that's about all it does if you don't use the new API.

[mojca (Mojca Miklavec)]

In 3699938/macports-ports:

wbxml2: upgrade to 0.11.4

• Upgrade to version 0.11.4
• Add cmake.out_of_source yes
• Avoid installing FindLibWbxml2.cmake to version-dependent location ${prefix}/share/cmake-3.7/Modules/FindLibWbxml2.cmake

See: #47197

[MarcusCalhoun-Lopez (Marcus Calhoun-Lopez)]

In 9cfde251/macports-ports:

nomacs: update version 2.0.2->3.4

Add cmake.out_of_source yes
See #47197

Links against latest opencv
See #48067

[Schamschula (Marius Schamschula)]

In c374f0ad/macports-ports:

FreeCAD: add cmake.out_of_source yes

See: #47197

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

In 72637ad08506bd55e5efaa9378e5c6b0bb0c2cab/macports-ports:

freealut: use cmake.out_of_source

See: #47197