gst-plugins-good dependency-limiting variant

[louis-francis.ratte-boulianne@…]

Add variant to exclude external dependencies

[jmroot (Joshua Root)]

Please remember to cc the maintainer.

[rmsfisher@…]

13. Ratte-Boulianne,
    

Regarding your proposed addition of gconf to the depends_lib section of the Portfile, the dependency will not be added for the following reason:
libsoup, which is already in depends_lib, depends upon libproxy which in turn depends upon gconf.
The addition of an explicit library dependency on gconf would be redundant.

Regarding your proposed variant, I would like to know why such a variant would benefit the userbase at large.
I try to make the ports I maintain depend upon external libraries which are enabled by default (i.e. dependencies with --without-foo or --disable-foo configure flags).
Your suggestion of a variant which does not depend on several free, open-source libraries confuses me.
If you can demonstrate a case in which such a variant would benefit other users I would take no exception to adding your variant to the distributed Portfile.
I look forward to discussing this with you so that we may update the Portfile and close this ticket.
Cheers,
Ryan Stonecipher

[louis-francis.ratte-boulianne@…]

Portfile patch

[louis-francis.ratte-boulianne@…]

13. Fisher

The gconf port was added because still needed even after removing libsoup from depends_lib (in the variant). I moved it into the variant section so it only gets added when libsoup is removed.

I have to admit my use case might be specific. I'm currently working on making sure that the whole Telepathy-Farsight-Gstreamer stack is working properly on OSX. Ideally, someone would then be able to build an IM/VOIP application using these elements. The problem is that to distribute that hypothetical application, you need to bundle every components together and a lot of the gstreamers elements are useless in that context. So, to slim down the package a little bit, I trimmed down unnecessary ext dependencies. I would of course prefer if this patch was "upstream".

AMSN is another example of applications that could use a slim gst-plugins-good port (it doesn't ship Gstreamer anymore because video-conference support is broken though)

[rmstonecipher@…]

I have revised the ticket title because 0.10.25 is the current stable, ported version of gst-plugins-good.

[mf2k (Frank Schima)]

This port no longer exists.

[jmroot (Joshua Root)]

It was renamed.